The Good Dictator? Mohammed bin Salman’s Quest to Stability Progress and Repression

In Saudi Arabia, an absolute monarchy has woven a hanging paradox: a society the place private satisfaction typically rivals that of democracies, at the same time as repression stays a cornerstone of its rule. The newest FII Precedence World Survey reveals that 84 % of Saudis specific contentment with their lives, lifted by free healthcare, low inflation, and increasing financial and social freedoms. Critics contend this happiness is a brittle assemble, engineered by a state that criminalizes dissent. But, for a rising era, these beneficial properties have bred a loyalty so deep that Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman—referred to as MBS—may nicely triumph in a hypothetical election, regardless of the dominion’s lack of democratic establishments. Unelected however comparatively attuned to public needs, the Saudi authorities has threaded in style aspirations into its formidable Imaginative and prescient 2030, crafting a picture of stability and well-being that veils the autocracy’s unyielding suppression of opposition.

This satisfaction comes from a system the place energy is inherited moderately than contested, and accountability depends upon the monarchy’s self-directed reforms. Not like democratic leaders, whose authority rests on elections and clear governance, MBS operates in a realm that prefers order and citizen welfare above political pluralism. The Saudi state’s mission—to safeguard stability, shield its individuals, and elevate societal well-being—is taking form with out democracy, delivering a top quality of life that, by some measures, outstrips Western nations. Nonetheless, this progress sits alongside a grim reality: dissent is silenced, and the monarchy’s maintain stays absolute. MBS’s drive to ship prosperity and alternative upends the idea that good governance calls for democratic norms, posing thorny questions concerning the trade-offs between freedom and stability.

Skeptics typically attribute Saudi Arabia’s prosperity on its finite oil wealth, however Imaginative and prescient 2030 paints a broader image of calculated diversification. In 2024, non-oil exports hit a file $137.29 billion—a 13 % soar from the prior 12 months and a 113 % leap since 2016—propelled by petrochemicals, plastics, fertilizers, metals, and nascent fields like know-how, renewable power, and agriculture. MBS’s strategic investments have fortified the non-oil economic system, aiming to spice up its GDP share from 40 % to 65 %. This shift not solely shields the dominion from the looming decline of oil reserves but additionally bolsters the monarchy’s legitimacy, as a thriving, different economic system underpins the social contract sustaining his rule.

Imaginative and prescient 2030 is a daring roadmap to recast Saudi Arabia as a worldwide financial pressure whereas cementing monarchical stability. Born from the necessity to break oil dependency, it options audacious ventures like NEOM, a $500 billion futuristic metropolis, and the Crimson Sea Mission, a luxurious tourism haven, alongside investments in renewable power and infrastructure. By pushing non-oil GDP development and concentrating on overseas direct funding at 5.7 % of GDP, the plan seeks to place Saudi Arabia into the world’s high 15 economies. MBS underscored this imaginative and prescient in a Fox Information interview, describing the exceeded targets and new objectives for resilience and international competitiveness. —a glimpse of his foresight in seizing untapped potential.

Past economics, Imaginative and prescient 2030 doubles as a social pact, locking within the monarchy’s legitimacy by assembly the ambitions of Saudi society, particularly its youth. With out elections, MBS has woven public needs into targets like lifting girls’s workforce participation from 22 % to 30 %, doubling UNESCO heritage websites, and growing family spending on tradition and leisure to six %. Initiatives like Qiddiya, an leisure megacity, alongside investments in schooling and international connectivity, nurture a dynamic society rooted in Islamic values and nationwide satisfaction. By syncing authorities plans with societal calls for, he dampens dissent and bolster authority via inclusive progress.

This mix of alternative and reform additionally fortifies MBS’s political safety, neutralizing threats to the established order. Saudi Arabia’s climb from eightieth to twentieth on the Authorities Effectiveness Index and a tenfold surge in non-oil income sign stronger establishments. Outreach to youth, paired with cultural and financial openings, builds a loyal base much less more likely to defy the crown. On the worldwide stage, from restarting ties with Iran to forging regional logistics hubs, MBS secures the dominion’s standing, defending his rule. Imaginative and prescient 2030’s promise of prosperity and stability anchors his management—each visionary and iron-fisted.

But, beneath the sheen of Imaginative and prescient 2030 and Saudi Arabia’s push to host the 2034 FIFA World Cup lies a human rights disaster that contrasts with its modernizing picture. In 2024, the dominion executed at the least 338 individuals—a precipitous rise from 170 the 12 months earlier than and the very best in a long time, per Amnesty Worldwide and AFP counts. In accordance to Amnesty Worldwide, activists face relentless crackdowns, with arbitrary arrests, unfair trials, and harsh sentences for difficult the regime. Take Muhammad al-Ghamdi, a retired instructor sentenced to demise in July 2023 for peaceable on-line posts, convicted by a Sharia-based court docket that features even non-violent critics.

MBS known as the al-Ghamdi case “shameful” in a September 2023 Fox Information interview, blaming “unhealthy legal guidelines” and vowing reform. But, as mega-projects and cultural spectacles dominate headlines, stories of executions and stifled freedoms fade. He introduces a state the place custom meets international integration, however persistent harsh penalties trace at a regime chasing acclaim whereas repressing at house. As international scrutiny will increase, these abuses threaten to puncture the dominion’s narrative of progress with out accountability.

Saudi Arabia’s human rights file clashes with MBS’s sweeping social reforms, which have reshaped the cultural panorama whereas galvanizing conservative pushback. By 2025, girls’s workforce participation hit 37 %—overshooting Imaginative and prescient 2030’s aim—fueled by curbs on the spiritual police and new roles within the navy. The 2017 anti-corruption purge underscored his resolve to streamline energy and modernize governance. However these steps are eclipsed by ongoing abuses—338 executions in 2024, extreme sentences for expression—tied to a Sharia judiciary. MBS walks a tightrope, dealing with resistance from clerics and traditionalists who cling to conservative norms, testing his bid for a progressive but authoritarian state.

MBS’s rule embodies securitization, casting reforms and repression as twin pillars of stability. Imaginative and prescient 2030 tackles existential dangers like oil dependency, whereas executions are framed as shields towards dissent. This echoes authoritarian playbooks the place safety spans narrative management and financial futures.

Can top-down change ignite lasting social shifts with out political pluralism? Saudi Arabia mirrors Singapore and China’s authoritarian modernization, however its deep cultural conservatism—embedded in courts and society—complicates MBS’s imaginative and prescient. Progress with out democracy is feasible, seen in financial leaps and social openings, but international watching the executions and silenced voices. Can a nation so expert at spinning a story of progress reconcile its ambitions with the hidden toll of these it mutes, or Will MBS’s imaginative and prescient at all times waver between reform and repression, forcing us to confront the uncomfortable actuality of the ‘benevolent dictator’?”

Additional Studying on E-Worldwide Relations